HMDA Action Taken Rates : Adjusting for Loans Purchased

This is the first in a series entitled HMDA Insights : Capitalizing on New Perspectives prepared to provide mortgage lenders with advanced analytical insight to enhance governance, risk management and compliance activities in a challenging – and changing – environment.

Link to PDF Version

Summary:

  • Excluding Loans Purchased (i.e., Action Type 6) in evaluating a lender’s lending profile is necessary as the purchase decision is distinct from the origination decision.
  • Mortgage TrueView HMDA Insight Dashboards[1] show that differences between the aggregate Action Taken Rates[2] inclusive of all Action Taken codes (i.e., Gross Rate) and aggregate Action Taken Rates excluding Loans Purchased (i.e., Net Rate) are significant (Chart 1).

   Chart 1 | Comparative Action Taken Rates | 2010 – 2014 

Chart1

  • While the overall results are noteworthy, it is essential to evaluate – and understand – the results in the MSAs/MDs where a lender conducts business.

Analysis:

Insight1_Table1

Loans Purchased by all HMDA Respondents and the relationship of such applications to Actioned Applications (i.e., Action Taken Codes 1-5,7 and 8) (“Loans Purchase Rate”) are significant (Table 1).

Mortgage TrueView Insight Dashboards show MSA/MD-specific 2014 Loan Purchase Rates ranging from 1.42% to 37.41% (with the range for the top 20 MSAs based on Actioned Applications ranging from 13.30% to 26.57% as shown in Chart 2).  

 

      Chart 2 | Loans Purchased as a Percent of Actioned Applications [Top 20 MSAs/MDs] : 2014

Insight1_Chart2

Mortgage TrueView Insight Dashboards show that the St. Louis, MO-IL MSA has the highest 2014 Loan Purchase Rate – 26.57% – among the top 20 MSAs based on Actioned Applications.  Table 2 presents the Top 20 lenders (based on Total Applications) in the St. Louis, MO-IL MSA and shows their respective Loans Purchased Rate.  Table 2 shows that the St. Louis, MO-IL MSA Loans Purchased Rate of 26.57% is primarily attributable to 8 (highlighted) lenders that have Loans Purchased Rates significantly higher than the average Loans Purchased rate for the St. Louis, MO-IL MSA.

Insight1_Table2

Four of the eight lenders – Respondents 4, 8, 14, and 19 – show significant Loans Purchase Rates with Respondent 19 reporting 1 Actioned Application and 1,359 Loans Purchased.

Despite significant Loans Purchase Rates, two of the eight lenders – Respondents 2 and 10 – also show significant Actioned Applications, 3,973 and 1,028, respectfully.

It is clear from Table 2 that including Loans Purchased as Approved Applications significantly misstates the lending activity for the highlighted lenders.  By extension, including Loans Purchased misstates the lending activity for all lenders and provides an inaccurate view of lending activity for the overall market.

* *

Our next HMDA Insight will focus on how adjusting Action Taken rates makes a difference in establishing a more meaningful benchmark for purposes of evaluating lending activities.

* * *

“It is a capital mistake to theorize before one has data. Insensibly one begins to twist facts to suit theories, instead of theories to suit facts.” ― The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, A Scandal in Bohemia

* * * *

[1] Mortgage TrueView Dashboards can be accessed by 2015 HMDA Survey participants using their complementary access credentials.  Non-participants may obtain credentials by sending a request to hmda@mortgagetrueview.com.

[2] Approved includes loans originated, applications approved not accepted, and preapproval requests approved but not accepted.  Denied loans include applications denied by the financial institution and preapproval requests denied by financial institution.


© 2016 Mortgage TrueView, Inc.  | All Rights Reserved.

This material may not be used for any commercial purpose in whole or part without the express written permission of Mortgage TrueView, Inc.

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *